In my opinion, this is the first time in ten seasons we've seen actual sincerity from an "American Idol" judge!

Jennifer Lopez seemed to take it harder than the eliminated contestant Wednesday night when she broke down in tears after telling Chris Medina that he would not be moving on in the competition.

Medina had been a fan favorite with his touching story of caring for his fiance who was left brain damaged by an accident shortly before they were supposed to wed. The episode ended on a cliff-hanger, with Lopez claiming that she couldn't proceed with the eliminations.

Keep reading to see for yourself.